Author Selection

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

The Canadian (History) Pandemic

As I sat down this morning to start my daily readings I came across something that shocked and appalled me. The Globe and Mail had an excellent piece on the lack of teaching of Canadian History within the High School classroom's all over Canada. Appropriately, they called the article, "Canada is failing history." The entire article is worth a read, but these facts alone were enough to make me cringe:

"The results, found in the just-released Canadian History Report Card (the full report is available at report-card.dominion.ca), are troubling. The institute's analysis of provincial and territorial curriculums revealed that:

  • Four provinces failed and deserve the F they received;
  • No province received an A;
  • Only four provinces - Quebec, Ontario, Manitoba and Nova Scotia - require Canadian history as a mandatory course in high school. The others do not;
  • Most provinces simply offer courses in “social studies,” catch-all courses that generally ignore Canadian history (with the notable exception of British Columbia)."

Now of course being a history student immediately makes me biased, however, how can a nation who claims to be so proud of their "peacekeepers," multiculturalism and way of life know next to nothing about their own history? Are people simply falling into the stereotypes that are brought up when a snippet of our nation's past is seen on a ten minute CBC video clip? Maybe. Or is it perhaps because we as Canadians tend to be too humble and choose to ignore our accomplishments and sacrifices that have helped create this country we call Canada today? There is no right or wrong answer other than that Canadians don't know or seem to care about their past.

The Dominion Institue nailed the issue right on the head,

"The Dominion Institute recommends that a core body of knowledge and terms of national significance be developed and included in all history curriculums across the country. It is unacceptable to think that students can graduate from high school without learning about the First or Second World War, Canada-U.S. relations or about the history of aboriginal Canadians."

In my opinnion that's a generous statement. What about the entire history of French-English relations in Canada? The execution of Thomas D'arcy McGee and Louis Riel? What about the founding of the West and the war of 1812? Of course, it would be naive to think that all of these events could be covered in a one year high school history class, but maybe that's the problem - one credit in our nation's history is simply unacceptable.

Our youth and even elderly are not nearly as educated as I would imagine our American counterparts are in their own history. American history is ingrained in the minds of American youth through history books, countless Hollywood movies, memorials and commemorations. Of course, some say that Americans are "too" patriotic, whatever that's supposed to mean, but one thing is for sure we as Canadians are not patriotic enough when it comes to celebrating our history.

Regardless, Canadians cease to care or remember their own history because it isn't placed within most people's reach. You have to look, research, read and understand the glorious past that this nation has. So while you're drinking beer, spending cash on fireworks and lighting up the BBQ this coming Canada Day (July 1st) take a second and learn something about our history. For if we don't start too, I fear it may be lost forever in our apathetic shadow.

Full article: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/opinions/canada-is-failing-history/article1184615/

- Ty

Monday, June 15, 2009

René Lévesque Bio Pic on the CBC

Well I was fortunate enough to tune into the CBC last night, and what might I find? Well the continuation of the René Lévesque bio pic. Now I was unfortunate enough to have missed the first part (aired some two years ago), but I was lucky to catch the second part (both airings last night and tonight). Now like many of my fellow Canadians who had been watching the NHL playoffs, there was not one mention of the continuation of this series among the many beer commercials. But luckily I caught it anyway.

Now I have a slight problem with the biography, well maybe multiple slight problems, so where do I start? Well first I have a feeling that the emotions and atmosphere have been lost in the English version. It looks as though the best take was probably in French, leaving the actor to try and recapture that moment in a language slightly unfamiliar to him. Furthermore if you are going to recapture a moment as significant as the defeat speech after the 1980 referendum, then why not show the original footage, after all its not as though the CBC does not have it. Then again that is something I have been looking for in bio films altogether.

Next, what happened to Colm Feore? Is he too busy to reprise his role as Trudeau? Well I guess so, because they had to find another actor to play the part; just a slight let down.
Aside from the poor acting and some slightly off casting, this program did deliver in a way that is truly commendable. While the name Lévesque in Québec is as well known as the hockey franchise, the same cannot be said in other areas of the country. Far to many times while reading Graham Fraser's book "René Lévesque and the Parti Québécois in Power" was I asked "who is that?" while when reading a book with Trudeau's name little was asked because it is Trudeau. Nevertheless, this documentary does educate those lucky enough to have caught it, on who René was and what he was fighting for.
Ironically while I criticize the acting, I have for the first time seen René in a light that truly is not conveyed in the written words. For the first time I find myself saying "oh poor René." Of course this holds many questions as to how accurate the acting is and what message is being portrayed, but maybe for the first time the story of a Québécois has been portrayed to all masses without the usual negative stigma associated with French politics. However only time will tell. Let us hope that next time this appears on television there is some advertisements because this story needs to be heard outside of Québec and those few who watch the CBC.
Z.R. Nissen